We built our barn right after we purchased our house, which was almost 16 years ago. I have drug my feet on finishing it. This spring, we're getting ready to tackle the barn, and I am paralyzed, yet again, with the decisions about breezeway flooring, stalls, and stall fronts.
For every option, there is a pro and a con. Currently, the breezeway is a dirt floor, and a dirt floor, though not attractive, is extremely safe and comfortable for the horses. The stalls are the same. They are dirt floors with lots of woodchips. The horses love it, and it allows me to customize them. Cowboy is old and arthritic, as was Old Red, and for them I mound up dirt so that it is at a steep incline. When they lay down, it makes it very easy for them to get back up. The stalls are harder to clean and the woodchips cost a small fortune, but again, au natural has many pro's. Attractiveness is not one of them, but comfort certainly is.
Decisions, decisions.
I'm tempted to use concrete in the breezeway and tack room. It's easy to clean, and it's simple. I can place our rubber mats over the portions where they are tied, as we do now. The con of concrete floors is that they are slick, but rubber mats would help with that.
I just read of another option, popcorn asphalt. It has better traction and is more porous to allow water and urine to permeate.
Have any of you had experience with popcorn asphalt?
As for stalls, I'm pretty sure I want to build them up and use stall mats. Dirt, gravel layer, mats--or something like that. I'll let my husband research the base of the stall floors. But I may keep a couple of them natural for the older horses, or perhaps, clay flooring, that is also moldable?
The stall fronts will probably be wood with a yoke opening. The reason I haven't already done the stall fronts is because we need to take them off to bring in more dirt, and our tractor is big. Permanent stall fronts will make removal much more difficult. Kind of makes me think that if we do the stall fronts, we will have to also do the stall floors so that they don't need that kind of semi-annual maintenance.
The easiest decision of all is about the tack room. We'll definitely go with concrete in there. I'm most looking forward to that project, because it's the most straightforward. I know what I want and need, but it's harder to know what the horses would like best, since they can't talk.
I welcome your thoughts and experiences with barns as I, hopefully, finally, make these decisions.